What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
Moderators: LawBeefaroni, $iljanus
-
- Posts: 48
- Joined: Sun Jan 28, 2007 1:46 am
What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
What do you think will have if Putin crosses this line? What do you think should happen?
Personally, I think that if he uses nuclear weapons the US/NATO should make a conventional response--the reports that sinking the Russian Black Sea Fleet would be under consideration would seem to be a good start.
What do I think WILL happen? If Putin goes nuclear I think a base in Western Russia gets a dose of instant sunshine.
Personally, I think that if he uses nuclear weapons the US/NATO should make a conventional response--the reports that sinking the Russian Black Sea Fleet would be under consideration would seem to be a good start.
What do I think WILL happen? If Putin goes nuclear I think a base in Western Russia gets a dose of instant sunshine.
- Kraken
- Posts: 44067
- Joined: Tue Oct 12, 2004 11:59 pm
- Location: The Hub of the Universe
- Contact:
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
I've read that Biden has a contingency plan and it has been communicated to Putin. I don't think it involves a nuclear reprisal, more likely a massive conventional NATO response.
- Defiant
- Posts: 21045
- Joined: Tue Oct 12, 2004 11:09 pm
- Location: Tongue in cheek
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
I'm thinking Putin thinks this, based on past performance:
- LawBeefaroni
- Forum Moderator
- Posts: 55466
- Joined: Fri Oct 15, 2004 3:08 pm
- Location: Urbs in Horto, outrageous taxes on everything
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
Depends on the yield I'd imagine but at minimum it would mean the end of their Ukraine ambitions and we'd see pre-2014 borders.
Remember that tactical nukes can be relatively low yield so it can be more of a matter of crossing the philosophical nuclear line than inflicting massive damage or ecological disaster.
Remember that tactical nukes can be relatively low yield so it can be more of a matter of crossing the philosophical nuclear line than inflicting massive damage or ecological disaster.
" Hey OP, listen to my advice alright." -Tha General
"No scientific discovery is named after its original discoverer." -Stigler's Law of Eponymy, discovered by Robert K. Merton
MYT
"No scientific discovery is named after its original discoverer." -Stigler's Law of Eponymy, discovered by Robert K. Merton
MYT
- Kurth
- Posts: 6081
- Joined: Tue Jan 04, 2005 1:19 am
- Location: Portland
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
But I’m not sure what this gets Putin. Why cross that philosophical line if you’re not going to get a military advantage out of it? Does he seriously think that the global reaction to him going nuclear — even if low yield — will be to back off? It will just convince the world even more that he is a global threat that must be dealt with.LawBeefaroni wrote: ↑Tue Sep 27, 2022 4:04 pm Depends on the yield I'd imagine but at minimum it would mean the end of their Ukraine ambitions and we'd see pre-2014 borders.
Remember that tactical nukes can be relatively low yield so it can be more of a matter of crossing the philosophical nuclear line than inflicting massive damage or ecological disaster.
This is why I don’t think Putin will go this route. It’s not really plausible to me, unless he’s completely unhinged and not a rational actor at this point.
Just 'cause you feel it, doesn't mean it's there -- Radiohead
Do you believe me? Do you trust me? Do you like me? 😳
Do you believe me? Do you trust me? Do you like me? 😳
- LawBeefaroni
- Forum Moderator
- Posts: 55466
- Joined: Fri Oct 15, 2004 3:08 pm
- Location: Urbs in Horto, outrageous taxes on everything
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
I don't see him doing it but I didn't see him trying to go all the way to Kiev either.
Bad information can make people do really dumb things.
And I was trying to get at the fact that the response is based on the line being crossed rather than the explosive yield. Don't expect muted response to a small 10t explosion.
Bad information can make people do really dumb things.
And I was trying to get at the fact that the response is based on the line being crossed rather than the explosive yield. Don't expect muted response to a small 10t explosion.
" Hey OP, listen to my advice alright." -Tha General
"No scientific discovery is named after its original discoverer." -Stigler's Law of Eponymy, discovered by Robert K. Merton
MYT
"No scientific discovery is named after its original discoverer." -Stigler's Law of Eponymy, discovered by Robert K. Merton
MYT
- YellowKing
- Posts: 30378
- Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 2:02 pm
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
Heck, at this point who knows if he could even get his top brass to sign off on such a strike. I've seen articles suggesting the ordering of a nuclear deployment could just result in the last shreds of his military command turning on him.
- Kurth
- Posts: 6081
- Joined: Tue Jan 04, 2005 1:19 am
- Location: Portland
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
That’s another reason for optimism that Russia isn’t about to play the nuclear card: Not only would Putin have to be entirely irrational, but he’d also need the Russian military to sign off on it. As little faith as I have in the Russian military, I think it’s highly likely an order to go nuclear would most likely be the end of Putin.YellowKing wrote: ↑Tue Sep 27, 2022 4:18 pm Heck, at this point who knows if he could even get his top brass to sign off on such a strike. I've seen articles suggesting the ordering of a nuclear deployment could just result in the last shreds of his military command turning on him.
Just 'cause you feel it, doesn't mean it's there -- Radiohead
Do you believe me? Do you trust me? Do you like me? 😳
Do you believe me? Do you trust me? Do you like me? 😳
- Holman
- Posts: 29182
- Joined: Sun Oct 24, 2004 8:00 pm
- Location: Between the Schuylkill and the Wissahickon
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
Speaking of which, yesterday was Stanislav Petrov Day.YellowKing wrote: ↑Tue Sep 27, 2022 4:18 pm Heck, at this point who knows if he could even get his top brass to sign off on such a strike. I've seen articles suggesting the ordering of a nuclear deployment could just result in the last shreds of his military command turning on him.
Much prefer my Nazis Nuremberged.
- The Meal
- Posts: 28006
- Joined: Tue Oct 12, 2004 10:33 pm
- Location: 2005 Stanley Cup Champion
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
I can't see him trying the nuke tactical strike either. It's embarrassing when your tanks don't work so well. What is it if your nuke doesn't go off (right away)?
"Better to talk to people than communicate via tweet." — Elontra
- Isgrimnur
- Posts: 82811
- Joined: Sun Oct 15, 2006 12:29 am
- Location: Chookity pok
- Contact:
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
It's almost as if people are the problem.
- Unagi
- Posts: 26761
- Joined: Wed Sep 20, 2006 5:14 pm
- Location: Chicago
- Jaymon
- Posts: 3030
- Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2008 12:51 pm
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
We are trying to apply reason and logic to what Putin would do. Very little of what he has done lately is reasonable or logical.
Bunnies like beer because its made from hops.
- hepcat
- Posts: 52187
- Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 3:02 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL Home of the triple homicide!
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
In my head, I'm seeing Putin Capricorn One-ing it by setting up a sound stage and projecting art from Fallout 4 on the backdrop as someone frantically wails "Utter destruction as Russian nukes go off in the Ukraine!"...then a kid pushing a bike accidentally walks across the screen because they forgot to close the set to the public.
Now depoliticized.
- LordMortis
- Posts: 70478
- Joined: Tue Oct 12, 2004 11:26 pm
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
I was seeing Slim Pickens meets the Gremlin with a hammer from Bugs Bunny.
- El Guapo
- Posts: 41538
- Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2005 4:01 pm
- Location: Boston
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
I'm not sure that's true. His actions make sense (even if he's not always smart about how he executes things) in the context of what he thinks and what he is after. He seems to genuinely believe that Ukraine is a kind of fake nation that is and should be properly part of Russia (at least the bulk of it). As long as Ukraine remained a vassal state loyal to Russia, he could live with it having nominal independence. But after the pro-Russian government fell in 2014, Ukraine tilted firmly towards the west, and various efforts to destabilize it / bring it back into line (the Crimea seizure and the separatist fighting in Ukraine's east) failed, there wasn't much prospect on the horizon of Ukraine coming back into the Russian fold.
Given that, Putin could essentially do nothing, which would likely lead to Ukraine drifting further and further away from Russia and into the EU / Western orbit. Or he could launch an invasion - obviously that's risky, but nothing all that bad came out of the Crimea action, plus his advisors were all presumably telling him that they could roll over Ukraine in a week. And if they had...the western sanctions would be bad, but might well have been livable.
Whereas with nukes, it is hard to see how using nukes would help him win in Ukraine. On top of that, it would greatly increase the risk that the west directly intervenes in the UKraine fighting, and the risk that western leaders push to oust Putin himself. Is it possible that Putin miscalculates? Sure. But hard to see him making the call.
Black Lives Matter.
- Carpet_pissr
- Posts: 20225
- Joined: Thu Nov 04, 2004 5:32 pm
- Location: Columbia, SC
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
Just chiming in to say Putin doesn’t SEEM to be acting irrationally/unstable enough to use nukes. Miscalculations and some bad results coming from an inept army, sure.
- LawBeefaroni
- Forum Moderator
- Posts: 55466
- Joined: Fri Oct 15, 2004 3:08 pm
- Location: Urbs in Horto, outrageous taxes on everything
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
Keep in mind that tactical nukes are much smaller, require less by way of chain of command to release and use, and may already be possessed by any number of operational units. They have already used the same delivery systems (Iskander, etc) in their Special Military Operation. It's not like their equivalent of the Joint Chiefs have to turn keys in unison or anything.Kurth wrote: ↑Tue Sep 27, 2022 4:20 pmThat’s another reason for optimism that Russia isn’t about to play the nuclear card: Not only would Putin have to be entirely irrational, but he’d also need the Russian military to sign off on it. As little faith as I have in the Russian military, I think it’s highly likely an order to go nuclear would most likely be the end of Putin.YellowKing wrote: ↑Tue Sep 27, 2022 4:18 pm Heck, at this point who knows if he could even get his top brass to sign off on such a strike. I've seen articles suggesting the ordering of a nuclear deployment could just result in the last shreds of his military command turning on him.
" Hey OP, listen to my advice alright." -Tha General
"No scientific discovery is named after its original discoverer." -Stigler's Law of Eponymy, discovered by Robert K. Merton
MYT
"No scientific discovery is named after its original discoverer." -Stigler's Law of Eponymy, discovered by Robert K. Merton
MYT
- hepcat
- Posts: 52187
- Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 3:02 pm
- Location: Chicago, IL Home of the triple homicide!
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
Honestly, I think Putin will fall back on his KGB training and go more for assassinations, sabotage and other forms of warfare he can use that will still allow him to deny any involvement as the war goes on. I think he'll then spread that around increasingly to countries supporting Ukraine as well. I believe we've already seen that with the pipeline incident recently.
He's a despotic tyrant who is capable of great acts of evil, in my opinion. I'm betting we'll see more and more of that as the pressure for a win/withdrawal from inside his country increases.
He's a despotic tyrant who is capable of great acts of evil, in my opinion. I'm betting we'll see more and more of that as the pressure for a win/withdrawal from inside his country increases.
Now depoliticized.
- El Guapo
- Posts: 41538
- Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2005 4:01 pm
- Location: Boston
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
Everything else aside, what I have read about tactical nukes is that they're not all that useful against conventional military units. Given the delay in targeting vs. hitting the targets, and conventional units ability to, well, move, destroying a conventional army with nukes vs. just hitting them with a shit ton of artillery doesn't make much sense. So there's not much reason in that for Putin to use them.
Black Lives Matter.
- LawBeefaroni
- Forum Moderator
- Posts: 55466
- Joined: Fri Oct 15, 2004 3:08 pm
- Location: Urbs in Horto, outrageous taxes on everything
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
They can be delivered exactly like conventional artillery, rockets, and missiles. That's the whole point. Same package, bigger boom.El Guapo wrote: ↑Thu Sep 29, 2022 4:02 pm Everything else aside, what I have read about tactical nukes is that they're not all that useful against conventional military units. Given the delay in targeting vs. hitting the targets, and conventional units ability to, well, move, destroying a conventional army with nukes vs. just hitting them with a shit ton of artillery doesn't make much sense. So there's not much reason in that for Putin to use them.
" Hey OP, listen to my advice alright." -Tha General
"No scientific discovery is named after its original discoverer." -Stigler's Law of Eponymy, discovered by Robert K. Merton
MYT
"No scientific discovery is named after its original discoverer." -Stigler's Law of Eponymy, discovered by Robert K. Merton
MYT
- Grifman
- Posts: 21392
- Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 7:17 pm
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
The problem is that modern armies are fairly dispersed. Any bomb big enough to do serious damage would threaten his own forces, unless he aimed at an HQ or logistical hub.LawBeefaroni wrote: ↑Thu Sep 29, 2022 4:47 pmThey can be delivered exactly like conventional artillery, rockets, and missiles. That's the whole point. Same package, bigger boom.El Guapo wrote: ↑Thu Sep 29, 2022 4:02 pm Everything else aside, what I have read about tactical nukes is that they're not all that useful against conventional military units. Given the delay in targeting vs. hitting the targets, and conventional units ability to, well, move, destroying a conventional army with nukes vs. just hitting them with a shit ton of artillery doesn't make much sense. So there's not much reason in that for Putin to use them.
That said, I think the Western response depends upon the nature of the attacks. What if Putin does a demonstration attack on Snake Island as a warning? What if he hits a military HQ or logistics hub? What if he hits Kyiv or Lviv? I think each of those calls for a different response.
I think very little happens if there is just a demonstration other than NATO starts moving assets to show/warn Putin - they call his bluff. If he attacks a military target, then I think NATO attacks significant Russian military asserts. If he hits a major city, then NATO launches an air campaign to destroy the Russian army in Ukraine.
That said, from my reading I am very concerned he will possibly launch a nuke attack.
Tolerance is the virtue of the man without convictions. – G.K. Chesterton
- Holman
- Posts: 29182
- Joined: Sun Oct 24, 2004 8:00 pm
- Location: Between the Schuylkill and the Wissahickon
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
Yeah, there is really no tactical use for nuclear weapons. Their tactical effect can be easily matched by conventional weapons without crossing the nuclear line.
Maybe the only exception is a "small" nuclear strike that cripples a naval fleet at sea, but even then there are strategic/political effects that a conventional strike wouldn't introduce.
Maybe the only exception is a "small" nuclear strike that cripples a naval fleet at sea, but even then there are strategic/political effects that a conventional strike wouldn't introduce.
Much prefer my Nazis Nuremberged.
- Blackhawk
- Posts: 44696
- Joined: Tue Oct 12, 2004 9:48 pm
- Location: Southwest Indiana
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
Especially when you are attacking upwind.
(˙pǝsɹǝʌǝɹ uǝǝq sɐɥ ʎʇıʌɐɹƃ ʃɐuosɹǝd ʎW)
- Holman
- Posts: 29182
- Joined: Sun Oct 24, 2004 8:00 pm
- Location: Between the Schuylkill and the Wissahickon
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
I assume there is some back-channel communication going on, and that the message is that tacnuke strikes in Ukraine will be met with conventional strikes on all possible launch sites of such weapons.
The point isn't to persuade Putin but to suggest to local Russian commanders that their special keys actually don't work.
The point isn't to persuade Putin but to suggest to local Russian commanders that their special keys actually don't work.
Much prefer my Nazis Nuremberged.
-
- Posts: 48
- Joined: Sun Jan 28, 2007 1:46 am
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
I've seen a couple of articles (can't speak for sources) stating the Russians were told that the use of a tactical nuclear weapon in Ukraine would result in the destruction of the entire Russian Black Sea Fleet.
- Carpet_pissr
- Posts: 20225
- Joined: Thu Nov 04, 2004 5:32 pm
- Location: Columbia, SC
Re: What if Russia uses tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine?
Petraeus:
He told ABC News: “Just to give you a hypothetical, we would respond by leading a Nato – a collective – effort that would take out every Russian conventional force that we can see and identify on the battlefield in Ukraine and also in Crimea and every ship in the Black Sea.”
Asked if the use of nuclear weapons by Russia in Ukraine would bring America and Nato into the war, Petraeus said that it would not be a situation triggering the alliance’s Article 5, which calls for a collective defense. That is because Ukraine is not part of Nato – nonetheless, a “US and Nato response” would be in order, Petraeus said.
Petraeus acknowledged that the likelihood that radiation would extend to Nato countries under the Article 5 umbrella could perhaps be construed as an attack on a Nato member.
He told ABC News: “Just to give you a hypothetical, we would respond by leading a Nato – a collective – effort that would take out every Russian conventional force that we can see and identify on the battlefield in Ukraine and also in Crimea and every ship in the Black Sea.”
Asked if the use of nuclear weapons by Russia in Ukraine would bring America and Nato into the war, Petraeus said that it would not be a situation triggering the alliance’s Article 5, which calls for a collective defense. That is because Ukraine is not part of Nato – nonetheless, a “US and Nato response” would be in order, Petraeus said.
Petraeus acknowledged that the likelihood that radiation would extend to Nato countries under the Article 5 umbrella could perhaps be construed as an attack on a Nato member.